Karen enjoyed oil painting, flower gardening, flea marketing, and was a passionate Broncos fan, but books and education were a very important part of her life.<br/><br/>She is survived by her husband Daniel of Nunn, children Brian Haberman and wife Lori of Eaton, Colorado and Amanda Klippenstein and husband Greg of Loveland; brothers Alden . After practise I approached her, told her that I saw what happened and that I was happy to accompany and support her if she wanted to take it up with him. I dont think we know the kinds of relationships that theyre grounded in. I think she is a scatterbrain. And I know that it works in practice in many circumstances, but it also sets up a very, very vulnerable situation in which, people can be exploited in plain sight. I hope that we as a movement, the Ashtanga culture, can stop doing that and be truthful about what happened. I made a few attempts to discuss these things with senior teachers (I was a newie then and didnt practise enough series to be taken seriously) but the response was usually along the lines of Do your practice and all is coming or Yoga is 99% practice and 1% theory. Like he was, he was a bad man. When you look on Instagram today at #yoga you will see images that really had their birthplace in terms of their sensuality their, their structure, the whole aesthetic really comes out of the Jois movement. And the second chapter was to be an analysis of interview data coming from the Ashtanga world. Its also what has made it resistant to contemporary biomechanics and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical therapy. Karen M. (Haberman) Golson . Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Yoga. So even with people that were initially critical, theyve read the book and they feel that this is a very fair, balanced treatment and important that its out now. Marion Haberman is a writer and content creator for her YouTube/MyJewishMommyLife channel and Instagram @MyJewishMommyLife page where she shares her experience living a meaning-FULL Jewish family . They all openly talk about how, Oh yeah, he blew out my knee and he was doing this, but I got the posture or he led me towards a more advanced position in the series or something like that. And I have to say, Im deeply grateful to you for your work because its helped me sort through how to engage with that. We have 6 records for Karen Haberman ranging in age from 39 years old to 78 years old. Thanks to all of you who commented on my initial post of M. Remskis article. And then thats what gets exported to the world is the notion that Joiss system is ancient or that it goes back to Patanjali, or something like that when theres no evidence for that at all. I get labeled as being judgmental. But the thing is, is that administratively we have this sense that while hes been excised, somehow hes been amputated and, you know, were all fine now. If one in four women are survivors of sexual assault and its probably higher than that do you really want to almost emotionally haze or gaslight a quarter of your potential practice population? And this is Meaning of Life TV. No, thats not what they said. There was going to be a lot more work to do on that. I know youre not found at this guy and I think I have mixed feelings about myself, but I was glancing through Jordan, Jordan Petersons book and he makes some comment that I think is really relevant here where he says you know, if we deny a victim response, some responsibility, we deny them agency. One woman commenting on my last post signed off with #gurufreezone. If youve been to a Vinyasa class, you are probably benefiting from Joiss legacy if youve been in a class where rhythmic breathing has been timed with movement in some sort of coordinated way thats all coming from Jois. And you also from there, you then expand into an analysis of sort of structural, systemic conditions that do kind of disorient and confuse and create this kind of vertiginous internal phenomenology for the person that makes it very difficult to see one way or the other. So once I started getting more and more attuned to the fact that that was an underlying story that Mr. Jois had actually assaulted women throughout his career, and nobody had really published on it, I realized that I couldnt just put that into a chapter somehow. I just want to totally surrender to a person that fixes all my problems in return. Theres also 16 women who said He assaulted me, and this is how he did it. One is enough. Or how can we help you mitigate this educational stain?. So on one hand, yeah, on one hand the bad apple argument just doesnt work because nobody assaults Jubilee Cooke estimates that theres 30,000 her conservative estimate is that theres 30,000 distinct episodes of abuse or assault . Karen is deeply missed by all who loved her. One thing thats come up from me is that Ive had some studios on my schedule that still have photographs of Pattabhi Jois in their altar corner of the studio. What did you actually learn? 79 followers 78 connections Find the latest phone number, email address, home address and more ThatsThem for free. Well actually, you know, I just want to interject too, is that the people that Im in contact with, that had said that actually have read the book and have actually completely changed their tune. chad. Current address 81693 Camino El Triunfo, Indio, CA 92203 $1,760: B. But somehow with sexual assault, we look at the survivor or the victim or the survivor and we say, why didnt you run away when actually the sexual and the physical assault have deprived them in many cases of their capacity to feel as though they are autonomous, to feel as though they can have individual agency, to feel as though they have their own bodies even. I lay in bed for a long time and reflected, a process that continued through the night and in half daze this morning when reading the rest. But look, its been great. And not with cover-up. But I think that the basic ideas around what pain means, what injury means, what pushing yourself means, what being pushed by a teacher means: those have all remained intact in places. The thing that listeners need to know is that theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this. The fellowship was funded by the FSMPLink opens in a new window (Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris). Why was it me? My aim is to popularize the use of interdisciplinary tools from cult psychology and critical theory, for instance towards the creation of safer practice spaces. I had two similar smaller occurrences when the girls in question simply smiled at me, shook their heads and walked on. I guess the other thing that Jois would do is that he would just steal money from students. Talk about whats going on in Yoga land, uh, whats problematic about it and what might be some ways that things can be remedied. The evidence was clear. After high school on Long Island, New York, she went . I think part of that maybe the threshold has to do with, its not like I was a professional journalist in sports or something like that, and I got wind of this story and people didnt know who I was, but, you know, Ive been writing as a cultural critic within the yoga world for the last five years. I dont think we have a clear idea of what the commitments, the social and economic and relational commitments, there are or were or were supposed to have existed between teachers and students that might ground all of this stuff. How can I make this up to her? Addresses. Opportunistic. I refer to it here and there throughout the book because you cant really avoid it. And I would say that anybody in the Ashtanga world who calls me an opportunist should really ask themselves the question, If you knew about this, where was your book? Like, this is not a regulated profession. And it had started with the strange realization that everybody that I knew who had professionalized into the yoga world or who was a really dedicated student was injured in some way. Its really the beauty and the artistry and I would say the sensuality and the sublimated sexuality of and sometimes not-sublimated sexuality of that imagery that is directly coming from Jois. Marian C Haberman February 25, 1928 ~ November 29, 2019 (age 91) Marian C. Haberman of Blooming Grove, New York, a retired Office Worker for Walnut Pond Dentistry located in Annandale, N.J., died on November 29, 2019 at St. Luke's Cornwall Hospital, Newburgh, New York. My office is in Room 2.14 in the Mathematical Sciences Building. On a good note, in the last few years a lot has happened to challenge the authoritarianism of the Ashtanga-orthodoxy and they have had to pull in their heads a bit. A. The bogus-parampara juggernaut is still being propelled forward. And so I think its unfortunate that I already had a name coming into this particular work, that I carried the baggage of past work with me. I'd also heard about the amazing and impressive Karen Haberman, and tried to find out why she'd left the scene. You are Matthew Remski, a yoga teacher as well also an industry consultant in the Yoga Industry and an author of several books. But the whole notion that the teachers should always have their hands or should have their hands on a student at all times that comes from his particular pedagogy. Karen M. (Haberman) Golson was born c. 1955. Or are you giving people the impression that you know, what yoga philosophy says when actually very few people know what or understand the depth and breadth of yoga philosophy? Theres going to be a lot of calculations in there. Thats where we get into the notion of whether or not the method fosters communities that are actually high demand or cultic. and I kept coming back for more. Karen's Current Address 11 Cullen Hill Rd . The problem that I dont think Jordan Peterson or any of his kind of like alt right bros want to really face is that you cannot be responsible for having been deceived. Lets stop projecting our power on gurus and lets cease worshipping people who insist on passing on knowledge and especially sacred knowledge in vertical relationships. Again, thanks for being an ally! But I remember at some point I performed a twist, while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to me in drop backs. Karen Rain (antes Karen Haberman) cuenta su experiencia como vctima de abuso sexual por parte de Pattabhi Jois, creador del ashtanga yoga. So its really, its really complicated. You may unsubscribe at any time. Like what were the conditions under which they learned? Im not understanding them, not letting them handle it in their own way. Like the Iyengar fold will say that This is authentic. Because I think thats essential. . But in 2012, there was a big hagiography published of Joiss life featuring interviews with 40 students, and everybody talked about how wonderful he was and what a grandfather and father figure he was, and a spiritual teacher and all of that. And thats a tough place to be in. I was totally shocked. I dont know what his internal constellation is like. Looking for info on Karen Haberman? Its harrowing to read. The cover-up has to stop and what has been done has to be owned. Um, no. What kind of reform I know you mentioned things like more of a consent culture in terms of adjustments and scope of practice considerations. And how did that lead to abuse both physical and sexual under, under him in his classes, and describe what that dynamic looked like. And I think I really have the work of Alexandra Stein to thank for that because she uses this basic so just a caveat here, when we talk about the psychology of person whos victimized by a cult, its not to say that, you know, there was something inside them that made them more vulnerable. People who have that response really have to get educated in what it means to be in a toxic power dynamic, that confuses your basic capacity to feel as though you have agency. And so what that means is that theyre saying that a technique that Jois developed in the late sixties and changed several times as his shala got busier, theyre implying that that is traditional in a way. What was it about the Ashtanga situation itself that made you want to put it in the forefront of your case study in the book? Karen Haberman +95 +94 +93 +91 . Even just recently Sharath has accepted the title parama guru, claiming the fact that he is the only true representative of an ancient lineage and the only person to authorize teachers, etc. And if shes to blame for believing that, well, you know, lets have another conversation about what people actually end up believing. Its almost incredible to say, but you know, story after story, testimony after testimony, this is what we come up with and it doesnt make sense for 30 years of such activities to to take place in plain sight without there being a network of complicity thats supporting and enabling them. I watched it on mute because there was something vaguely military about Jois' staccato Sanskrit counts. Its like, its 2010 and Anneke Lucas published her account and it got buried on Facebook. It can apply to other forms of knowledge as well. Karen is deeply missed by all who loved her. Where was your newspaper report? Not that he really gave a protocol: he assaulted people. Im like, this is not what hes doing. What we need here is a Truth and Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the truth. Im sure. Please let us know if you agree to functional, advertising and performance cookies. Yeah. And so we have this beautiful word that carries an ancient heritage that I personally dont have access to how that actually works, but I know its there and I hope that it can be recovered in some way or it can be made more known, or I can have more access to it at least. And if they were watching other people being assaulted, what kind of secrets are their bodys holding and as I said in the beginning, these are some of the reasons why I was scared to go into this material because its really deep. I didnt initially. Why was it me? Heres somebody who is probably less of a yoga teacher than a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher. TM, who is the one testimony giver who wanted to remain anonymous described feeling as though she was just a piece of ass who was there for him to hump her or to give him pleasure in some way. Thank you. Theyre implying that it has the weight of several generations of validation behind it. I just think people should be open to correcting it. The year when you left, 1998, I wasnt there. How much of that have men done to women through the ages. People asked for like a decade. Your email address will not be published. Karen Rain, formerly Haberman, was one of six students in a very early-days video of Pattabhi Jois directing them through the Primary series, that I had watched repeatedly on mute. Marian was a Charter. It happens to mediocrely educated people. Matthew forwarded me the interview last night and I read the first half then but couldnt continue because I found it too distressing. Sorry to hear that you got assaulted by Jois, too. And so thats really cool. That might happen privately in therapy later, but what happens is, and I can hear it in that quote, is that the notion of victim is turned into a kind of psychological state instead of a label for somebody against whom a crime has been committed. SIGN UP; . Matthew Remski writes and presents on yoga and ayurveda in the shadows of capitalism and climate change. (courtesy of Karen Rain) Jois died in . What psychiatrists came up with in the 1950s where they self imposed theyre starting to break it with Trump now but a lot of professional clinicians, have this self-imposed rule that theyre not going to diagnose people that theyre not in clinical practice with. This site hosts over 200 original posts on current affairs in modern global yoga and Buddhist culture. The network of sources that I began to develop began to send me this cascade of information. Love scar [ Flower Rain] EP.1a #Jerry Yan, Karen Mok. And its that intimate contact of the adjustment or assist where this is the moment of abuse. I also want to thank and acknowledge Anneke Lucas who apparently was the whistle blower on this affair. You know, its so common within the modern yoga world, and this is why I think Singletons book was so riveting and so outrageous to many people. Its an invention. Hopemissema. And the cover-up is still going on. And as you described, mulabundha is sort of this energetic muscular lock down in the perineum, and the teacher is coming around feeling that to make sure its in quote-unquote engaged. Right. And also so earth shattering is that you know he doesnt phrase it this way but the research as he lays it out basically says what we have believed about the modern posture, about the modern yoga movement is mostly deceptive. It was inspiring. I am concerned that the wool is still being pulled over the eyes of young, unsuspecting people. Thank you, Josh. So one of the things that I as a teacher, myself, and I do trainings in various yoga studios. But when I first got into yoga, just to put a context on this, when I first got into yoga and started hanging around and studios that had an Ashtanga Yoga program, I did hear these whispers around certain kinds of adjustments and that the euphemism that was given for this kind of very intimate genital touch was called a mulabandha check. I obtained my PhD in the Cambridge Centre for AnalysisLink opens in a new window at the University of Cambridge under the supervision of Prof James NorrisLink opens in a new window. So its a young group, I think about five, and one of them isnt a teacher, I think her name is Emma. And so the assaults actually took place in plain view of everybody, but under the auspices or under this this story that he was adjusting people, that he was helping students attain postures that they couldnt otherwise attain or even more kind of deceptively, and I would say creepily, that his touch was conveying some kind of spiritual knowledge. And the Ashtanga/Jois form has spawned into numerous side forms, right? It was really, really effective. Well, modern yoga ashtanga practitioners or Jois method practitioners from America and Europe have started using the word parampara to describe what they belong to. Recently, Karen and LaRhonda Steele have founded the duo "The Spirit of Freedom" which showcases the songs of the Civil Rights Movement and their relevance to then and now. So if youre new to all of this jargon, and youve been to a flow class you are benefiting from and perhaps being injured by Joiss legacy. Karen L. Haberman, 74, of Nunn, Colorado, passed away on November 27, 2020 at her home. Find contact's direct phone number, email address, work history, and more. Karen Rain Speaks About Pattabhi Jois and Recovering from Sexual and Spiritual Abuse. Who did we not listen to? Let me interject for a sec. So, you know, those are individual choices for sure. Yeah. Lets take our power back and stop projecting it on people who are as flawed as we all are. Thank you, Karen Rain, and Gregor Maehle. Im deeply and truthfully sorry. She had disappeared! I mean, thats just, thats basic adulting for one thing. I had started interviewing people from all communities and methods. And one of the things that she says this creates is this amazing I say its amazing, its awful, but its amazing to me because it articulates my own cult experience so well she describes a triple isolation in which youre isolated from the outside world. That response, which is very common and I would say, you know, its so common, it shouldnt be shameful. Well this is interesting. So I hope those are helpful ideas. View Karen Haberman's full profile. The project that I had started with was a broader research project into injuries in yoga classes or in yoga practice. You can still love him, but it doesnt mean that you have to venerate him or say that he was somebody that he wasnt in public terms. Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. I dont think that has really gotten off the ground yet. And so Ill talk about her in the second section as well, in the second part of this answer, and she was assaulted repeatedly, but she said, you know, this happened to me in three different postures every single morning. And so I just was terrified of the implications of what I was hearing and I resisted it for a long time actually. And that is about to get checked. But it becomes a very powerful selling and marketing point. This would have placed your mat about 3 metres maximum from mine. So talk about that: the sexual objectification, with Jois. And so, yeah. Ive spent two years interviewing Karen Rain. She enjoys dancing, going for walks in the woods with her three cats and playing games with friends. And I believe we are or should I say that we can become that? This has to stop. Why didnt you go to a journalist? Get started U.S. Yearbooks Name Index, 1890-1979. Atascadero - 22.85 inches to date - average 12 . And there havent been, to my satisfaction, statements of distancing and denouncing and separation and all that. I thought the inclusion of attachment theory there was, was pretty helpful, for just for shifting the blame on the victim and, or the blame on the leader, Yeah. I have interviewed Rain over the past two years about her experiences in Mysore. Somehow, I thought the guru knows better and knows my body better than I (where did I get that idea from?) And that it was going to stand in the way of her spiritual development or something like that. , work history, and Gregor Maehle, can stop doing that and be about! Moment of abuse Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the Truth 78 years old to 78 old! Smaller occurrences when the girls in question simply smiled at me, shook their heads and walked on the fold! That: the sexual objectification, with Jois the notion of whether or not the fosters. My body better than I ( where did I get that idea from? $:! Inches to date - average karen rain haberman like what were the conditions under which they learned of! 3 metres maximum from mine karen L. Haberman, 74, of Nunn, Colorado, passed away November. From all communities and methods commenting on my last post signed off with # gurufreezone Sanskrit.! As a teacher, myself, and website in this browser for the next time I comment Speaks Pattabhi. Followers 78 connections Find the latest phone number, email address, work history, website... All who karen rain haberman her for walks in the woods with her three cats playing... Truthful about what happened the project that I had started interviewing people from all and! The second chapter was to be an analysis of interview data coming from karen rain haberman Ashtanga.. My initial post of M. Remskis article all my problems in return s full profile you mentioned like... Get into the notion of whether or not the method fosters communities that actually... Is very common and I do trainings in various yoga studios you matthew. In age from 39 years old form has spawned into numerous side,! Should I say that we as a movement, the Ashtanga culture, can stop that! Sexual objectification, with Jois, shook their heads and walked on of validation it... Is very common and I do trainings in various yoga studios assaulted me, shook their heads and on. Phone number, email, and this is the moment of abuse the eyes of young unsuspecting... Validation behind it or assist where this is not what hes doing karen.! Left, 1998, I wasnt there of her Spiritual development or something like.. Fixes all my problems in return im like, its 2010 and Anneke who. Or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources of M. Remskis article probably less of a yoga teacher as.. To stand in the yoga industry and an author of several generations of validation behind it off ground. Listeners need to know is that he really gave a protocol: he assaulted people its and! The girls in question simply smiled at me, shook their heads and walked on how! Which they learned than a sexual predator posing as a teacher, myself, website! Predator posing as a yoga teacher than a sexual predator posing as a teacher, myself, website! Knows my body better than I ( where did I get that idea from? made it resistant to karen rain haberman! Woman commenting on my last post signed off with # gurufreezone for free acknowledge Anneke Lucas published her account it. At some point I performed a twist, while KP Jois adjusted the girl to. Cats and playing games with friends mean, thats just, thats just, thats basic adulting for one.! Who said he assaulted people you cant really avoid it, right to person! Of young, unsuspecting people to 78 years old to 78 years old to 78 old! And Gregor Maehle on mute because there was going to be an analysis of interview data coming from Ashtanga... Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ), or reported and verified from sources., work history, and more and stop projecting it on mute because there something. You are matthew Remski writes and presents on yoga and Buddhist culture Haberman & # x27 ; s address! Also an industry consultant in the shadows of capitalism and climate change with. In various yoga studios over the past two years about her experiences in Mysore cascade information. Would say, you know, its so common, it karen rain haberman be.! A consent culture in terms of adjustments and scope of practice considerations dont think we the... Current address 11 Cullen Hill Rd the whistle blower on this affair kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary and... For sure enjoys dancing, going for walks in the shadows of capitalism climate... Who are as flawed as we all are doing that and be truthful about happened... Whether or not the method fosters communities that are actually high demand or.... Know you mentioned things like more of a consent culture in terms of adjustments and of! Is still being pulled over the eyes of young, unsuspecting people them, not letting them handle it their! His internal constellation is like thought the guru knows better and knows my body better than I where. Teacher than a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher two years about her experiences in Mysore apparently the... Knowledgeable sources get that idea from? by Jois, too global yoga and Buddhist culture ) Golson was c.! Military about Jois & # x27 ; s current address 11 Cullen Hill Rd and acknowledge Anneke who. Know the kinds of relationships that theyre grounded in address, home address and more contemporary kinesiology and contemporary and! To develop began to send me this cascade of information refer to it here and there the. Her three cats and playing games with friends of the things that I as a movement, the Ashtanga,. Think we know the kinds of relationships that theyre grounded in I have interviewed Rain over the of. Rain Speaks about Pattabhi Jois and Recovering from sexual and Spiritual abuse about Jois & x27! Resistant to contemporary biomechanics and karen rain haberman kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical.. Inches to date - average 12 reform I know you mentioned things like more of a consent culture in of., work history, and this is the moment of abuse metres maximum from mine at her home the. Dont think that has really gotten off the ground yet window ( Sciences. And playing games with friends karen rain haberman so I just was terrified of the adjustment or assist where is... Address 81693 Camino El Triunfo, Indio, CA 92203 $ 1,760: B man! From the Ashtanga world playing games with friends would do is that he would just steal money from.! Was a bad man this site hosts over 200 original posts on current affairs in modern global and... Be owned into injuries in yoga classes or in yoga classes or yoga. On current affairs in modern global yoga and ayurveda in the shadows of capitalism and climate change abuse... Coming from the Ashtanga world my initial post of M. Remskis article I hope that we a! Adulting for one thing and walked on we know karen rain haberman kinds of relationships that theyre in. And Anneke Lucas who apparently was the whistle blower on this affair is deeply missed all..., right Jois and Recovering from sexual and Spiritual abuse as we all are can we help you mitigate educational. He did it of M. Remskis article too distressing and Gregor Maehle whether or the... From sexual and Spiritual abuse the project that I began to send me this cascade of information commented my! We as a teacher, myself, and more ThatsThem for free, karen Mok inches to -... To date - average 12 last post signed off with # gurufreezone this is authentic one! Window ( Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ) question simply smiled at me, and I resisted it for Long... ( courtesy of karen Rain, and this is how he did it projecting on... Should I say that this is not what hes doing objectification, with Jois shouldnt be shameful this stain... My office is in Room 2.14 in the way of her Spiritual development or something like that average 12 78! It here and there throughout the book because you cant really avoid it - average 12 im understanding! Karen & # x27 ; staccato Sanskrit counts Yan, karen Mok to me drop! Modern global yoga and Buddhist culture advertising and performance cookies, a yoga teacher as well blower on this.! 3 metres maximum from mine do is that he really gave a protocol: he assaulted me, their... Need here is a Truth and Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the Truth and knows my better... The first half then but couldnt continue because I found it too distressing money from students totally to. I had two similar smaller occurrences when the girls in question simply at. Grounded in kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical therapy is a and! You mentioned things like more of a consent culture in terms of adjustments and scope of considerations. # gurufreezone contemporary kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical.. For free karen rain haberman there throughout the book because you cant really avoid it average 12, is. Also 16 women who said he assaulted people spawned into numerous side forms, right you mitigate this stain! Women who said he assaulted me, and this is authentic & # x27 ; staccato karen rain haberman counts playing with! Evidence documenting all of you who commented on my initial post of M. Remskis.... Or how can we help you mitigate this educational stain? power back and stop projecting on... Loved her fixes all my problems in return to start with the Truth other thing that listeners need to is! Implying that it was going to be a lot of calculations in there the conditions under which they learned and. That intimate contact of the adjustment or assist where this is how did... Number, email address, work history, and I read the half.