I still have the SR22s. For a street price of around $450, you get three 16-round mags, a red dot-ready slide, a muzzle compensator, and a very nice trigger. Of course, when I was much younger I could hunt rabbits on a ranch with a riflebut no more! Thats the weak point of this design, because you need a tool in the form of a slave rod to capture the spring before you can reassemble the gun. Therefore theres less threading the needle involved in getting the gun back together. The Ruger had the odd condition that if the trigger were pressed with the mag removed, the trigger would go rearward and stay there. Mine is the compact version. That means lubricating the internals and sometimes the ammo and magazine with excess oil. Height 4.9 inches 4.5 inches. One of the easiest slides to rack, good crisp trigger, and I prefer the grip angle much more than the luger pattern models you apparently prefer. The trigger is surprisingly good, no doubt a product of the simple single-action design more than anything, but thats okay. Best shooting Semi auto for me was a PPK I was allowed to try. Our Team Said: We ended up being not so fond of the Ruger. Using CCI Mini-Mag, one of my favorite all around .22 LR loads, I was obtaining 10-shot, 25 yard groups averaging 2.8 with the Walthers and 2.2 with the Rugers. Volquartsen discovered the P22 extractor wasn't shaped correctly and offers a replacement part for less than twenty bucks. If youre going to carry an easy-to-shoot .22, this is the way to go. Have you had a chance to check it out? Please don't reference guns as toys and young adults as kids. The single action pull is relatively crisp and clean after a fairly significant amount of take up, a nice surprise considering most guns in this category and action have atrocious DA pulls. Just a fun and comfortable pistol to shoot and work with. Good shooting. The Ruger SR22 is definitely a better gun but it is vastly inferior to Ruger's MK and 22/45 series of pistols - especially the trigger. The slide is aluminum alloy, as is the barrel-retention block and the slide rails inside the frame. Capacity is again 10+1. Mine shoot just fine and have proven to be reliable guns with over a decade of use! If youre a Glock fan but dont want to fool with 9mm or above, then the G44 is for you. GOOD TARGET PISTOL Just called him and if it's available we'll get it. We acquired a new Ruger and borrowed a locally owned, new-condition P22 for this test. I don't hunt squirrels or small game my Buckmark IS a FUN TOY for shooting paper and plinking! Would the PPQ be a good choice for a starting handgun? Hey Matt, Thanks for the write up on the 22lrs. Smith & Wesson approached the design with their typical eye on quality of materials and design. Give it a rating below. The trick in operating safeties of this nature is swiping the extended, raised thumb down and past the safety to pop it forward and up to the fire position, much more easily accomplished thanks to the small size of this gun. The Buckmark requires you to remove the slide bridge, which is annoying enough by itself. Contrary to what I've seen on YouTube, this pistol did not explode, the slide did not crack, the extractor did not fall out of the gun.. The top of its anodized slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of the Walthers dead-flat black with longitudinal serrations. By far it was easier to use a finger of the weak hand to press the button. This is especially surprising considering Walther guns have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general. Thanks for the great article. Every gun owner should own at least one .22 LR firearm. I was able to buy the unit which has the extra cylinder for 22 mag. Walthers P22Q is a modestly updated and modernized version of their rightly famous P22, first introduced way, way back in 2002 werent helped to usher in the era of the so-called tactical rimfire; smaller, full-featured handguns that replicated the overall layout and control characteristics of semi-auto service pistols. We found it annoyingly hard to depress the button, and when we got our thumb into position to press it, the remainder of our hand blocked the magazine from ejecting. Get proficient on YOUR time. I have 3 mags so 90 rounds of pure accuracy and no stopping the fun. SR22 has both sites dovetailed into the slide, far more robust. Both are entirely functional, and have only minor gripes associated with them. To clean the other two Luger knockoffs, you have either a button to push or a pin to rotate, and thats pretty much it. This is a hurdle that can be overcome but it will only be overcome through disciplined practice and application. A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. Ill second that! Other than the ammo-sensitivity, they run well and obviously expensive .22lr is still relatively cheap compared to 9mm/.40. With similar features and promises of performance being likewise promised, is choosing one or the other just a matter of brand? So if you're having issues with you .22LR pistol, I would try different ammo before you blame the gun. Looking forward to your commentsthank you..Mike. The rear sight is adjustable for windage with elevation being adjusted by replacing the front sight with one of several included various heights. besides all that, the Taurus TX-22 also eats and fires all kind of 22 ammunitions, whereas the P22, ISSC and others are too picky and will only cicle with hot expensive top noch 22. Or if youre lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. Then (yep!) And I have shot a charter arms pathfinder in a .22 /.22 magnum, and really like it.but stopped to think about over night and it was gone the next day. Hey there. These were CCI Green Tag Competition, Eleys Match EPS, CCI Mini Mag solids, Winchester Power Point HP, and Federal Classic High-Velocity. Id take either one of those over any you have listed. Check out our full review of the SW22 here. Like just about every mag-fed gun on this list, it comes in a 10+1 capacity and a 5.5-inch bull barrel. Both the Ruger SR22 and the Walther P22Q are fine rimfire pistols that are suitable for a variety of tasks, from informal target shooting and plinking to the honing of fundamentals and even self-defense. Though the sights are a cheap polymer, theyre more than accurate enough for self-defense distances. The .22 LR version is a 10-shot model available with a 4-inch and 6-inch barrel. We suspect Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we havent seen it done yet. Mossad agents eventually killed Salameh in Beirut in 1979, using a car bomb. None of these .22s are inspire by the Luger. On the evening of 21 July, 1973, a day after having misidentified Bouchikhi as Salameh, Mossad agents in Lillehammer, Norway, carried out the assassination. MSRP: $439-479 (depending on the model). Due to a striking physical resemblance, Mossad agents mistook Ahmed Bouchikhi, a Moroccan waiter with no terrorist connections, for Black September operative Ali Hassan Salameh. The TX22 brings a striker-fired, polymer-framed pistol at an affordable price point. With the Walther it is possible to carry the gun safely with the hammer in the first notch with the safety off and youre ready to fire immediately in double-action mode before the gun transitions into a good single action trigger pull. Both guns feature magazines that are easy to load thanks to built-in assistance mechanisms, and the guns themselves are easy to charge thanks to minimal spring resistance against their lightweight slides, though the Walter is again somewhat easier to cycle even with the hammer down. Great Article. Will look forward to your future articles. We already have an account registered for email address Fortunately, as with any .22 LR, practice is cheap, and so is good ammo (relatively speaking), so no excuses. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. There is a very well written comparison between the Ruger SR22 pistol and the Walther P22 pistol at this website: SR22P vs P22 - brief review - WaltherForums After looking at the exploded diagram of each (I have an SR22) I can only say that those who say Ruger copied the P22 haven't looked closely at either. It's a nice compact SA/DA 22 semi & comes with two 20 Rd magazines as well as a decocker that drops the hammer without firing the pistol with a round still in the chamber. I have a P320 and after 2000+ rounds not one issue. Light weight. I could not think like that. But they did solve the worst problem with these guns with the single button take down and just as easy reassemble. towards your level. For them it is a training tool for my it is a TOY. It also has a ton of factory options available, which makes it easy to find the Buckmark that best suits your needs. There is no shortage of quality .22 pistols on the market today, and there is seemingly a model and accompanying variant that can suit any task or purpose. But the conclusion that one is trying to reach often says more about the person doing the testing than about the guns themselves. The Rugers 10-round magazines (two per gun) were a bit easier to load than the Walthers because they had a bump out either side that made it easy to press down the follower using two fingers instead of one. How about the M&P22? On the range we encountered perhaps the most damning thing about the Ruger, its trigger. I'll bet there will be some company to put out an extended mag but wouldn't see it past 15+1 less you want the mag to be as long as the barrel being that it is a single stack. My 110lb daughter shoots 9mm and 45 ACP. Windage was easy to correct with the screw-adjustable rear sight. Looking for ammo or rifles? How does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther P22? Alternately, the gun may be carried with the hammer back in single action mode and the safety engaged, meaning the safety only has to be disengaged and you are out of the gate with a light, easy trigger pull. So keep reading if youve been considering a .22 LR handgun. Weight is a feathery 16 oz., and it is nominally wider than the Ruger at 1 1/10 inches wide. 16+1? We give you some of our favorites based on price, accuracy, trigger, and more. Ruger SR22 vs S&W M&P 22 Compact - Which is Better? Each held ten rounds. I've seen countless Buckmarks and smith's malfunction. Now, press a button on the rear of the slide, and the gun opens up almost like an AR-15, ready to be cleaned, lubed, and reassembled without fuss. Personalize your experience. The rear sight on the Ruger is adjustable for windage and elevation as well whereas the Walther just for windage. A mechanical safety is ambidextrous and located rearmost on the frame in approximately the same position as a 1911, but curiously the safety is awkwardly pushed upward to place the pistol on fire and down to place the pistol on safe, contrary to the typical function of safeties in this location. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Gun Tests has been independently reviewing firearms since 1989. The safety blocks the hammer from striking the firing pin, and also locks the firing pin so the gun cant discharge. Move it down to the safe position and the hammer moves back a touch if its down, but doesnt drop if its cocked. What a moronic comment. Either is probably deserving of your money depending on your preferences, but my vote goes to the Walther. Also, ironically I'm finding (on-line) that the Walthers are going for about $85 (or more) less than the Walthers. S&W M&P 22 vs Walther P22 vs Ruger SR22 SoMD_Gen4 Mar 29, 2016 The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast Member Benefits: No ad networks! Walther p-22 is the worst. Probably at Ruger, waiting for its recall parts to be fixed. I'd say for a cheaper option that's not on this list, Bersa is definitely a good place to look. In a broader sense these are also general-purpose pistols; more or less equally at home in a self-defense role or a recreational plinking or target shooting role, and both are configured in such a way to be instantly comfortable for the vast majority of semi-auto pistol shooters today. Now, here is where things take a turn for the interesting: The examples of the Ruger SR22 that I have shot consistently turn in better groupings across a variety of different brands of ammo than the comparative Walther P22Q examples. They can provide fun on the trail too, but personally wed prefer a gun with more accuracy if small-game hunting were on the schedule. .22 ammo at 5 cents a round? A laser sight there might make some sense for those with compromised vision. Thats neither a fault of gun nor ammo. sportsmans.com 369.99 View Deal Walther P22 Q For Sale Walther P22Q 8 more deals from guns.com 275.99 View Deal Walther P22Q .22 Lr 3.4" Pistol, Black -. Sweet performer. Six of the 15-member Mossad team (the shooters got away) were arrested by Norwegian police and sentenced to jail time from one to five years, but in 1975 all were returned to Israel. Sorry, I have no details about the make and model of the .22s they used. leeman357 1.78K subscribers Subscribe 467 41K views 3 years ago Ruger SR22 vs SW M&P 22 Compact - Battle of the Compact .22 Caliber. I hear good things about the M&P 22 Compact, that it's much better built than the full size M&P 22, which I think is made by Walther. His wife witnessing the shooting. Next is the ambidextrous magazine release, which is a latch device at the bottom rear of the trigger guard that you press downward to release the magazine. The rear site is both windage and elevation screw adjustable and the blade is reversible for dots or flat black. You can really stretch a box of ammo for several afternoons at the range. The disassembly latch is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the trigger guard. Bad ammo is bad ammo. The G44 offers a classic Glock lookseriously, it looks just like a G19, with similar dimensions too. The Ruger is no peach to reassemble compared to other pistols, but is a far sight easier than the Walther. It's a fantastic option though, and would probably be the .22LR not on the list that I'd be most likely to buy. First, it has the nicest trigger of the three Luger styles out of the box. Theres the ambidextrous safety, and though it operates in a reverse direction from that of many popular guns, its intuitive after a few seconds. As far as the aftermarket, rimfire handguns and rifles (particularly the Ruger 10/22) have a ridiculous number of aftermarket manufacturers with triggers, stocks, conversion kits, sights, extractors, magazines, mag releasesthe list goes on and on. Does it have enough accuracy? My favorite has got to be the Ruger SR22. All in all, it was an excellent little gun save one thingit only worked when it felt like it, and overly tight tolerances meant you got one mag of reliable function out of it before it needed cleaning. The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. 22 magnum costs more than 9mm and MUCH more than 22LR, at least around here. A captivating story of a post-apocalyptic United States. I know Lone Wolf had them for $250 a while back. One correction. For aftermarket accessories, Id recommend Tandemkross, just like I would for the Ruger and the Smith above. It is a different story for the Ruger, with a heavy, glitchy and snaggy double-action pull and an indistinct single action pull, although the single action pull weight is entirely acceptable for a gun of its type. It's definitely a good choice if you've got the dosh for it. I've owned a dozen, or so, 22lr handguns. Just a great overall gun. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, the 1911. However, both guns refused to reliably function with Federals Classic High Velocity ammo, and with our final match-ammo test. While one of us was in Alaska running a trap line, the handgun was kept warm in a shoulder holster. Thoughts? Hmm, shoulda, coulda, day late and a dollar short. Other than that it has been flawless! We recently launched a brand new ammo search directory. Like the Walther, it ran 100 percent. The SIG P320 is striker fired. (If Ruger or Walther decided to do it, we suspect a great many fans of James Bond would buy the guns just for the fact that they look like the famous PPK. Walther P22 Model WAP22003 22 LR, $379 Walther also has a version with a longer barrel, and one with an integral laser sight for $479. The Walther is not made by Walther, it's junk and best avoided. I have come to prefer the SR22 for a several of reasons. The gun could not be carried cocked and locked. I know there are roughly a billion other options out there, but these are just a handful of our favorites. Its safe, cheap, and fun so why not. The same thing happened with the Ruger. Add in the lightened slide, adjustable rear sight, plus locked-in reliability and accuracy, and you have a winner, winner chicken dinner! It is grippy in most conditions can afford a more secure purchase for all shooters. If one is only trying to determine where a gun measures up across any number of mechanical characteristics youll find that such testing is fairly scientific and relatively easy to do in a repeatable fashion so long as one is careful. I might be looking for a different set of characteristics than you are in a specific handgun for a specific purpose, or in anything else for that matter. Nary a failure to fire, eject, and chamber. Keep the oil out of the barrel and off the grips. WIIL TRY GET RUGER 10/45 NEXT TRIP GUN STORE We dont recommend that method. It would appear that $$ is going to sway me, with which I'm not necessarily comfortable. And if this hypothetical gun were far more accurate than either of these two test guns, wed beat a path to the makers door and buy one for ourselves.) I know this one is an antique - but I the I am a proud owner of a High Standard Model 107 Supermatic Citation Military 5 1/2 " barrel - with the original box - and it is pretty BA. Not quite. I like the Ruger and will start there for comparing. Ruger SR22 Pistol Caliber: .22 Long Rifle. The simple fix was to cycle the hammer again with the DA trigger on the P22. That's an awesome story, Grady. I have yet to experience a single malfunction with my TX-22. Like the Mark IV, its a 10+1 capacity, mag-fed firearm with a bull barrel, typically a 5.5-inch one. But both guns magazines were easy to manage. I am a new gun owner and bought a ISSC M22 (i bought it on a whim and did no research) it shoots well enough but the ONLY ammo it takes without jamming is CCI Mini mags. I have many favorites! Magazine: 10 Rounds. Kel Tec PMR 22 WMR.. Lightweight-13.6 OZ of pure awesome. If you ever do a followup to this article "6 Best .22LR Pistols/Handguns [Hands-On]: Tiny & Awesome" I might suggest the Glock 44. Who cares what your daughter shoots? If your hands are sweaty or wet this does not inspire confidence or provide much security. Walther's P22 Target was the only test gun with a polymer frame. You'll now receive newsletters of our best articles on techniques, I have a Ruger mk 2 target that will eat pretty much anything I put though it. you a link to reset your password. As a comparison test, we fired one of our 45 autos loaded with Cor-Bons PowRball, and put five into a ragged one-inch hole at the same 15-yard range. This is certainly more in line with the modern preference for highly customizable polymer frames but regrettably Ruger went out of their way to make this as difficult as possible; removing and installing the grip shells is extremely challenging compared to the simple installation of the Walthers backstrap accomplished only by drifting out a single roll pin. The slide release is located immediately above and behind the trigger and is generously proportioned for easy actuation. Where the rubber meets the road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and little else. We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe. Would love to see them re-engineer the magazine to hold more than 10. These guns are compared and contrasted atop gun shop counters every, single day all across the nation. Next in line is a model 41 S&W. Until it's not. anything extra and your I don't shoot it very much any more, but when I do, I have Fun!. It offers simple controls and a 16-round capacity in a flush fighting magazine. PS: Goats have kids people have children. I own both the Walther and the Ruger. It annoyed us to much we tried an old gunsmiths trick on it that helped it a lot. A disassembly latch tab is located well out of the way inside the trigger guard and set into the ceiling near the front. Type your new password and hit button below to confirm it. If youre used to shooting centerfire cartridges of any size, this gun is going to feel like an absolute pushover by comparison. The trick is to simply push the recoil spring guide rod all the way through its front aperture with the spring in place, and then hold it there with your supporting hand while guiding a slide back over the barrel and on to the frame before releasing it. I just read the review of the glock 44. Best trigger with overall accuracy was the old High Standard Victor. I cant sing the praises of the GP-100 enough. The new QD model solves this issue and updates the classic design. Many .22 caliber pistols show a certain amount of ammunition sensitivity. I was considering that for myself for cheaper ammo / practice vs. buying another .22LR gun. Where is the Sig P322? It's one of my personal favorites. All others things being said, a trigger on a gun you otherwise really like, can be fixed. Getting the new sight in was tricky. The P22 is potmetal and the three or four that I've shot of other peoples have been jam-o-matics.